Good art or bad art: You decide

by Dan in Misc > Art Opinion

Published Nov. 12th 2006

How do you view art?

It used to be that anything called “Art” had certain meaning attached to it. Art was assumed to be beautiful, intricate, expensive. . . crafted with care by a master. Sometimes it told a story, or marked a special day or event.

Art was universally revered, instantly recognized, and generally approached with awe, while today it is looked at much differently.

Viewers generally respond to works of art in one of the three following ways:

1. Enjoyment

Some people like a particular work simply because it pleases them. The colors, the shapes, the good composition—all of it appeals to their senses. Or, they might enjoy a painting or sculpture because it’s worth a lot of money. They can feel the importance, the history of it, in the price tag or estimated value. Third, an individual may like a work of art because a friend or expert has told them it’s good, and they just accept it.

2. Dislike

People dislike art for the opposite reasons: It just doesn’t look nice; it’s not worth very much money; or someone has already told them that it’s not very good. In addition, it’s very easy to compare works of art, and dislike one based on your feelings for the piece hanging on the wall right next to it.

3. Disinterest

Possibly the easiest reaction to have, disinterest can be caused by confusion when looking at the work, or the viewer deciding that it doesn’t fit their idea of art and discounting it. It can also come from a decision against making the effort needed to understand the artwork, or just the fact that the piece doesn’t capture their attention.

Unfortunately, with art being as commonplace as it is, many artists and art experts are looking more and more for uniqueness in art above anything else. The art community tends to move from artist to artist, always searching for the cutting edge, the most daring, the strangest, even the obscene or shocking.

And the non-artists? They’re left in the dust unsure of why a particular work is special, and sometimes even lose that curiosity and awe they once felt when entering a gallery. They end up looking at price tags more than at the art itself and even begin to feel as though good art is just too deep and esoteric for their simple understanding.

What we as art patrons need to realize, however, is that we’re just as qualified to judge whether art is good or bad as any art critic. There’s no reason to sit back and nod appreciatively of a piece of trash hung in a gallery if in our heart we’ve already judged it to be a sham.

Tomorrow I’ll be writing more about a few specific works and how their uniqueness is either good or bad, and Friday’s article will be on how to judge art for yourself. No more guesswork, and no more faking it while feeling lost in a contemporary art exhibit. By following a few simple steps you’ll be able to easily categorize and explain why a particular work is good or not.

You won’t want to miss it, so make sure to bookmark this site and check back often.

Did you like this article?
Please stumble it so others will find it or check out the related posts below.
Finally, my "big project" is finished! It’s been a crazy day with a lot going on, but foliotwist.com is finally live and online! Since I’ve kept it a complete secret up until launch, here’s a quick (mostly visual) overview of what it does. . .read more
I’ve talked before about how to judge art, but today I’m going to explain why I think it’s important that all of us DO judge the art we come across, and speak up with our opinions about it. Personally, I believe there are some works of art that are better than others. You probably feel the sa. . . read more
Knowing the difference between good and bad art can be difficult. You can’t always trust the art experts; many times it’s hard to even understand them. Since I believe that it’s important to make up your own mind about art, I decided to write this article to help each and every one of you judg. . . read more
ArtfulHome.com is an online art gallery for North American artists which features all types of artwork and handmade decorations for the home. Whether you're looking to sell furniture, glass art, jewelry, or traditional wall art, Artful Home is the place to do it. Pricing and features of Artfu. . . read more
If you’re a college art major, or a talented high school artist, you might want to take a look at Ugallery.com. Ugallery is a new online art gallery specifically for students and recent graduates—and it operates a bit differently from many other online art galleries. First off, Ugallery is on. . . read more
Stay current.
Subscribe to EmptyEasel's free weekly newsletter for artists. Sign up today!
EE Writers
Lisa Orgler Luke Montgomery Gordie Carver Stede Barber Doris Glovier Rose Welty Robert Sloan

Want to be a writer for EmptyEasel? Paid positions are available, and the perks are great. :) Contact us to apply